IDEA
← Blog
46CostsCalculation · 5 min read

Should I even have a product developed based on my idea? A simple rough calculation can provide the answer.

Before you invest in the development of a product, you can check in just a few minutes whether it is even worth developing.

A product only pays off if the costs can be offset by the profit made from its sale. This must be assessed over the entire sales lifecycle. To do this, you need the price, realistic sales figures over the product’s lifespan, and the profit per unit.

Why do the maths first?

Many development projects start with a brilliant idea, without any initial consideration of the costs involved in developing it. It is possible that this brilliant idea solves a real problem, actually has a market, is genuinely good, and yet should not be developed.

The rough calculation below doesn’t take long. It is no substitute for a detailed business plan, but it does show at an early stage whether you need one. Our article What Product Development Really Costs – A Realistic View explains how development costs evolve over the course of a project.

The figures

  1. Start by asking what the willingness to pay for your product is. This is often not so easy to determine, but try to estimate it as realistically as possible. It helps to look at the competition and the market. Who is the target customer base? What other products does this customer base use? In which market segment does the product operate? When you establish a price range, the gap between the minimum and maximum simply adds to the uncertainty surrounding the final conclusion.

  2. Work out what sales volume can be achieved with the product – in other words, how many units you can sell within a given timeframe. This figure is not easy to determine either, and is often characterised by excessive optimism. Seek out contacts who can give you a realistic assessment. The more novel your product is, the more difficult it becomes to determine how many sales you can achieve. Are you solving a problem in a market for a specific group of buyers? How many people have this problem? How many can you reach through your marketing? How many will actually buy in the end? It helps to take a pessimistic view when estimating this figure.

  3. Work out the costs of developing your product. The more complex the product is, the more effort will be required to bring it to market. To do this, obtain quotes from several suppliers. Compare them and allow for a margin of error or unforeseen complications. A quote from a reputable supplier can easily be multiplied by 1.5 to adopt a conservative approach here too.

The calculation

Take the planned selling price and multiply it by the expected number of units sold over the product’s entire lifespan. Subtract tax from this gross sales price and apply a realistic profit margin, for example 10 per cent. You now have a figure which, after all other operational deductions, must cover the development budget.

If the development costs here already exceed the profit – then you do not have a viable product. You should not invest any further or commission any further development.

The rough calculation in four stages, from lifetime turnover through tax and profit share to the comparison with the development costs, with three cases shown as bars below. In the corkscrew case the development costs exceed the profit; for a simple part with many buyers they are far below it; in the borderline case the ranges of profit and costs overlap.THE CALCULATION1 · Lifetime turnoverSelling price× units over theproduct lifetime= 100 %2 · Taxesless taxesfrom the turnover3 · Profitrealistic share,e.g. 10 %= budget thedevelopment must bear4 · ComparisonDevelopment costs:quote × 1.5(pessimistic)Development costs > profit → not a viable productTHREE CASESProfit over the lifetimeDevelopment incl. × 1.5Range (min–max)A · CorkscrewStandard product already cheap→ do not developProfitDevelopment × 1.5B · Simple part< 10 components, many buyers→ development pays offProfitDevelopment × 1.5C · Borderline caseSales and price uncertain→ refine, decide on riskProfitDevelopment × 1.5The bar lengths show proportions only, not amounts.
Above is the calculation in four steps, below are three example cases. The profit over the product’s lifetime must cover the development costs including the mark-up; the bar lengths show proportions only.

Three cases

It is possible to develop a corkscrew that removes corks from bottles more effectively, with less effort and in a way that is easier for users. However, if the original product (a standard corkscrew) can be provided so simply and cost-effectively, no one will be prepared to pay the significantly higher price for a more elaborate solution.

If, on the other hand, you have a very simple product – a monolithic plastic component – or a product consisting of fewer than 10 components, and if your product solves a problem faced by many people, then you can expect lower development costs and high sales volumes, which will enable your product to hold its own in the market and make the development worthwhile.

The third scenario is the borderline case – where it is not entirely clear what sales volumes and selling price to expect. Of course, a great deal also depends on marketing – but you can treat this as a constant in all your calculations. It helps to set up this simple rough calculation in a document with variables so that you can play around with the minimum and maximum figures. If the result turns out to be negative, you can try to refine your estimates. What do you need to do to obtain more reliable figures? How can you increase sales?

Ultimately, you will have to make a decision based on the risk involved.

What makes the calculation sensitive

The calculation is highly sensitive to assumptions regarding sales volumes. If only 75 per cent of the planned units are sold, the profit falls to three-quarters, whilst development costs remain the same. A project that just about breaks even on paper therefore requires a contingency. How large this needs to be is a matter of judgement; there is no fixed threshold for this.

To put this into context: according to figures from the VDMA, the German mechanical engineering sector spent around 3.1 per cent of its turnover on in-house research and development in 2017; amongst companies that carry out research at all, the figure was 4.3 per cent; expenditure on innovation stood at 5.8 per cent. A single product whose development alone accounts for a double-digit percentage of its lifetime turnover lies well above this level and must justify this through price or volume.

Studies conducted since 1977 also show that at most around 40 per cent of new products fail; the often-cited figure of 80 per cent or more is considered a myth.

What you can do if it isn’t worth it

If the numbers don’t add up, there are several options available before you abandon the idea. You can scale back the scope of the development, for example by starting with a deliberately limited preliminary concept or a feasibility study; our article Feasibility study: when it pays off explains when such a study is worthwhile. You can refine the requirements, as unclear requirements are the most costly way to start; read What a requirements specification delivers — and when you need one for more on this. Decisions made early on can be changed cost-effectively, whilst issues identified late on are expensive to rectify.

How we handle this

If you describe your project to us, we will work through these considerations with you before you proceed to the development stage. If the project is not viable, we will advise you against placing an order with us for it.

Limitations of the calculation

The calculation has its limitations. All the figures entered are estimates, and product lifespans and sales volumes are assumptions that you must make yourself. It is no substitute for market research and says nothing about how reliable your estimates are. Its purpose is more modest: it separates ideas that can never pay off from those that deserve closer consideration.


Sources

  1. VDMA Volkswirtschaft und Statistik – Maschinenbau weitet Forschungsaufwendungen aus – the mechanical engineering sector’s internal R&D ratio stands at 3.1 per cent of sector turnover, rising to 4.3 per cent for companies engaged in research; innovation expenditure accounts for 5.8 per cent (2017 figures).
  2. Castellion, Markham – Perspective: New Product Failure Rates: Influence of Argumentum ad Populum and Self-Interest (Journal of Product Innovation Management 30, 2013, pp. 976–979) – empirical studies since 1977 show failure rates of no more than around 40 per cent; the commonly cited figure of 80 per cent is considered a myth.
  3. Ehrlenspiel, Kiewert, Lindemann, Mörtl – Kostengünstig Entwickeln und Konstruieren (Springer, 8th edition, ISBN 978-3-662-62590-3) – regarding the order of magnitude of the manufacturing costs specified in the design; figures of 70 to 80 per cent are cited in the literature.

IDEA e.U. · Determined Innovation

An idea you’d like to look into?

The more precisely you describe what you need, the more precisely we can tell you what it costs.

Should I even have a product developed based on my idea? A simple rough calculation can provide the answer. | IDEA